Supreme Court sends back cases against Hankook Tire and LG Electronics for reconsideration

The Supreme Court of Korea (Herald DB)
The Supreme Court of Korea (Herald DB)

The Supreme Court ruled that a company can be ordered to return gains from music played without permission at stores run by other businesses only if there is evidence that the company itself benefited from the music.

The court on Oct. 27 overturned lower court rulings in two cases brought by the Korea Music Copyright Association against Hankook Tire & Technology and LG Electronics and sent both cases back for further review, according to sources on Monday.

The Hankook Tire case concerned background music played at company-operated and franchised T’station stores from 2009 to 2016 under contracts with in-store music service providers.

The association sued Hankook Tire in 2020 for 146.92 million won ($110,000), saying it had authorized the providers to webcast the music and that playing it in stores required separate permission.

The lower courts found that the deadline for seeking damages had passed but ordered Hankook Tire to return about 9.42 million won in unjust enrichment.

They found that the company had helped infringe the association’s public performance rights and had benefited indirectly through franchisee recruitment and higher franchise fee revenue.

The Supreme Court said the franchisees were responsible for playing the music in their stores and that the association needed to show what concrete benefit Hankook Tire itself had gained.

It sent the case back to the Seoul Central District Court to examine whether franchisees paid Hankook Tire for the music service or whether the music actually helped it attract more franchisees or collect more in fees.

In the LG Electronics case, the association sought 267.92 million won over music webcast to LG Best Shop stores and played there from 2014 to 2016 without separate permission.

The trial and appeals courts initially ruled in LG Electronics’ favor, finding that the recordings qualified for a copyright exception for recordings made for sale.

In its first ruling, the Supreme Court held that the recordings had been made for use as in-store music and fell outside the exception.

The Seoul High Court then awarded the association about 40 million won, and both sides appealed.

In its latest ruling, the Supreme Court said any LG Electronics subsidiary operating the stores was a separate legal entity.

It found insufficient evidence that LG Electronics itself benefited from the music and sent the case back to the Seoul High Court.


shwang9@heraldcorp.com