With Kakao Bank on board, card issuers weigh the chance to win new customers against added costs
Kakao Bank's introduction of Apple Pay has ended Hyundai Card's run as the service's sole provider in South Korea, reviving a debate among other card issuers over the costs of joining.
Wider adoption of the service could give iPhone users more cards to choose from and more places to pay, but the question for issuers already squeezed by lower merchant fees is whether Apple Pay can bring in enough new business to cover the extra fees.
Kakao Bank added Apple Pay to its debit cards and to prepaid cards for teenagers on Monday, more than three years after Hyundai Card introduced the service in Korea.
For card issuers weighing the fees, one potential payoff is a jump in new card sign-ups.
Hyundai Card said it had issued about 355,000 new cards in the first month after introducing Apple Pay, up 156 percent from a year earlier.
Overseas spending by Hyundai Card's personal credit card customers rose 29.3 percent to 3.5 trillion won ($2.6 billion) in 2024 and another 11.7 percent to 3.9 trillion won in 2025, according to the Credit Finance Association. The company led its peers in that segment for three years through 2025 and has cited Apple Pay as a factor in its overseas performance.
For internet banks, more debit card spending can also mean more frequent use of the linked account and app. Toss Bank is reportedly targeting a year-end launch through a debit card partnership with Hana Card and has completed a review of its service terms.
"Our focus is on the long-term benefits for our customer base and the growth of our platform rather than the short-term profit or loss on each transaction," a Kakao Bank official said, adding the company expects Apple Pay to draw younger iPhone users and boost in-store debit card spending.
Broader adoption could also spur investment in terminals that support near-field communication, or NFC.
"The more issuers join, the more they're likely to invest in NFC terminals," a card industry official said on condition of anonymity. That would give existing Apple Pay users more places to pay.
Further expansion depends on whether more issuers decide the fees are worth paying. While Shinhan Card and KB Kookmin Card have reportedly done technical work and pursued reviews of their service terms, neither has confirmed a launch.
Although Apple Pay can help an issuer win spending from rivals, it can also add a fee when customers use an iPhone for purchases they would have made with the same card. Revenue from new spending has to cover the fees on both.
Applying Apple's reported fee of about 0.15 percent to the roughly 2 trillion won Hyundai Card processed through Apple Pay in 2024 would imply a payment of about 3 billion won. Apple Pay accounted for 1.1 percent of Hyundai Card's total card approvals that year, according to data it submitted to a lawmaker's office. The actual payment was not disclosed.
International card networks can also charge for digital tokens that replace card numbers in mobile payments. In 2023, the office of then-lawmaker Yoon Chang-hyun estimated that issuers would pay Apple and Visa about 342 billion won a year if Apple Pay captured 10 percent of Korea's credit card market. The estimate assumed fee rates of 0.15 percent for Apple and 0.20 percent for Visa.
Issuers are also watching Samsung Wallet, Apple Pay's main rival in Korea. Samsung Electronics kept the service free for domestic issuers in 2023 and said last year it was considering no fee. If major issuers join Apple Pay, Samsung could start charging for payments they already process through its wallet, industry insiders say.
Samsung is also a corporate client of banks affiliated with some card issuers, a tie that could influence their Apple Pay decision, the card industry official said. Internet-only lenders such as Kakao Bank have fewer ties, which could explain why it moved first. Toss Bank is preparing to follow.
The official expects most issuers to eventually offer Apple Pay, as falling merchant fees push them to look for growth.
"In the long run, I don't think high fees alone will keep issuers from adopting it," the official said. "Card companies have to find new ways to grow, and Apple Pay is one way to bring in new customers."
jwc@heraldcorp.com
