Back To Top

‘Lipstick effect’ hits China as economy slows

Chinese consumers more willing to spend on small indulgences such as cosmetics

Fang Jinqi, 32, said the most urgent thing for her at the moment is to develop a more thrifty lifestyle because her job as a property agent business is stagnating.

The big fan of Hermes bags who used to buy a new one almost every two months said she has not done so for at least six months.

To make up for the loss of her hobby, Fang is now turning to cheaper cosmetics, such as lipsticks, which she said “can be easily picked up from chain stores such as Sephora.”

Leonard Lauder, chairman of Estee Lauder Companies, said he noticed the sales of lipsticks experienced an usual rise during the economic deflation after the Sept 11 terrorist attacks in the US in 2001. Lauder said when the economy sours people are more willing to spend on smaller indulgences such as lipstick rather than splashing out on expensive luxury bags. It’s a phenomenon known as the “lipstick effect” and has been recognized historically.

Professor of sociology Juliet Schor wrote in her book The Over Spent Americans, published in 1999, that anti-wrinkle cream, moisturizers, eye shadow and powders, lipsticks and facial makeup can provide “hope in a bottle” for people, especially women, who are “looking for affordable luxury, the thrill of buying at the expensive department store, indulging in a fantasy of beauty and sexiness.”

In short, “Cosmetics are an escape from an otherwise all too drab everyday existence,” she wrote.

But is the same thing happening in China?

China’s GDP rose 7.8 percent in 2012, the first time that the country’s growth rate fell to less than 8 percent since 1999. Its economy grew 7.7 percent in the first quarter of this year.

The country’s Purchasing Managers’ Index dropped to a nine-month low at 49.2 points in August last year. A figure below 50 indicates a contracting economy. Fan Junlin, an economics researcher at the Agricultural Bank of China, said in an interview with the Xinhua News Agency: “Weak external demand remains the biggest factor dragging down China’s economic growth.”

But as the industrial and manufacturing sectors declined last year, fast-moving consumer goods and fashion brands soared. According to the market research firm Euromonitor International, the entire retail value of the beauty and personal care sector in China grew from 184.1 billion yuan ($30 billion) in 2011 to 202.1 billion yuan in 2012. L’Oreal Group saw its market share grow 11.2 percent in 2012 from 10.8 percent a year earlier. Shiseido Co and Unilever Group have both seen a 0.1 percent increase in terms of market share.
Young Chinese women try out the testers at a L’ Oreal SA cosmetics counter at a shopping mall in Beijing. (Bloomberg)
Young Chinese women try out the testers at a L’ Oreal SA cosmetics counter at a shopping mall in Beijing. (Bloomberg)

A survey of the global retail market released by the consulting firm A.T. Kearney showed China moved up from sixth place in 2011 to third place in 2012. It predicted the growth rate of China’s retail sales revenue will double by the end of this year despite rising labor costs and rents.

The German retail and wholesale group Metro AG opened 12 new stores in China last year to bring the total number to 64. It plans to have about 100 stores by 2015. Wal-Mart Stores Inc opened 30 new stores in China last year. Carrefour S.A. opened 18. Tesco Plc opened 13. Auchan S.A. opened 10.

Zara, a leader in the fast fashion industry, opened 31 more stores in China in 2012 to bring the total number to 123. Uniqlo Co, an overseas fast fashion brand in China, opened 71 more stores in China in 2012, bringing the total number to 184 by the end of last year.

Conversely, luxury brands saw their growth slow down in China in 2012 after years of astonishingly rapid rises in sales. According to the U.S. consulting firm Bain & Co, the growth rate in the Chinese luxury market fell to 7 percent in 2012 from 30 percent in 2011.

Italian brand Gucci said at the beginning of this year it would maintain the opening of new stores in China at three to four a year. At its height it was opening 10 to 15 stores annually. Bernard Arnault, chairman and CEO of luxury brand LVMH, said on Jan 31 that Louis Vuitton will not open boutiques in second- and third-tier cities in China in an attempt to avoid over-exposure.

According to Nick Debnam, Asia-Pacific chairman of consumer markets at KPMG China, the lipstick effect is an economic phenomenon where even when luxury spending slows, the spending on cosmetics tends to hold up pretty well. Cosmetics are relatively affordable compared with other luxury items and while people delay their bigger ticket luxury purchases, for cosmetics there is less deferral, or “switching of buying habits.” People are less likely to stop buying fast-moving consumer goods because they are seen as daily necessities. Debnam added that it does not necessarily mean the money saved by not buying luxury goods will be transferred to the purchase of daily necessities.

He added when the economy declines, some people will start to buy “relatively less expensive lipsticks or makeup to make themselves feel good.”

But he said he witnessed an improvement in the situation in the latter part of last year with sales gradually returning to normal, especially in Hong Kong. In the Chinese mainland market, he said things will get better probably in the second half of this year.

It’s not just cosmetics involved in the lipstick factor. It includes movies, as witnessed by the popularity of Charlie Chaplin films during the Great Depression in the US in the 1930s.

According to the former State Administration of Radio Film and Television, China’s box office sales hit 17.07 billion yuan ($2.74 billion) in 2012, surging 30.18 percent year-on-year and making the country the world’s second-largest movie market.

The low-budget comedy Lost in Thailand, which debuted on Dec 12, took an unprecedented 1.2 billion yuan in less than one month, out-earning Avatar and Transformers: Dark of the Moon to become the highest-grossing movie ever shown in Chinese theaters.

“Imagine how much a young guy has to pay for a two-hour date, including dinner, shopping and everything else. Check out the labels of whatever brand in the department store. A sweater will cost as much as 1,000 yuan. A Prada bag will cost the guy about 10,000 yuan if he really wants to give his girlfriend a special gift. The date can be very expensive,” said Liang Wei, founder and president of Beijing Magilm Pictures which specializes in marketing movies and is the largest company of its kind in China.

By Shi Jing

(China Daily)
MOST POPULAR